So today started pretty standard; I have volunteered to shovel the sidewalks at church, so I had to get up and do that this morning before 8 am (that's thanks to the so-called polar vortex and its effects here in Minne-snow-ta). Luckily, after I was done with that my wife and I went over to have breakfast with my grandmother. That was lovely. We also drove her to get groceries, since she stopped driving a few years ago. Then we came home and I tried to start a Twitter trend with #meaningfulchurchjargon.
I have to admit that it was a reaction. After settling into my recliner after the trip with Grandma to the grocery store, I had logged onto Twitter, thinking I would find out what's going on in the world and then get on with some other work after that. I think I may have got more than I was bargaining for.
Almost immediately, I stumbled upon a trend that had been started by Pastor Nadia Bolz-Weber. It was #meaninglesschurchjargon. People had globbed onto it and it took off. My interest was in it because I find NBW very thought provoking and challenging. But as I pursued the trend, I kept finding hurt after hurt...
Emergent church #meaninglesschurchjargon
— Randall Curtis (@RandallCurtis) February 1, 2014
'The bible clearly teaches.....'
#meaninglesschurchjargon
— Claire Alcock (@parttimepriest) February 1, 2014
Missional, emerging, incarnational, welcoming, inclusive, progressive, discipleship. Must I go on? #meaninglesschurchjargon
— Broderick (@HolaBrody) February 1, 2014
I also found some telling tweets too...
The problem w/ #meaninglesschurchjargon isn't so much that it's right/wrong, but that it shames people rather than points to a better way.
— Tyler Braun (@tylerbraun) February 1, 2014
.@Sarcasticluther
That uncomfortable moment when the #meaninglesschurchjargon becomes the only accurate way to describe your experience.
— Teo Bishop (@TeoBishop) February 1, 2014
I was perplexed. My blood boiled. Everything I thought was sacrosanct was laid bare for criticism... And I realized that it was just a chip in the dike and the flood waters would come running out at any time.To be honest, I have some of my own thoughts on strange words and phrases that Christians use without thinking. Some of them, I think, are resonant. Some of them sound silly. But I tend to keep many of my opinions to myself. So when I saw these flood waters start to gush out, I responded (with as much chagrin as I could muster):
@Sarcasticluther I've discovered that anything anyone has ever used as a buzzword is #meaninglesschurchjargon Hmm... how 'bout that?
— Tom Lutes (@lutes_thomasp) February 1, 2014
It felt foolish and mean. But it was my gut reaction that the hurt people have felt by others' words has caused them to start tearing down and criticizing everything, not for the sake of proof and deeper understanding, but because they just needed some way to lash out against the words and people who have hurt them.My wife suggested to me that I start a different trend, if I felt so passionately about it. And I scoffed at her because I have never been so popular as to start a trend. But when I was done, I gave it a try. I started #meaningFULchurchjargon because I wanted to see the things that gave people hope. I wanted to see the things that gave people energy and made them come back again and again to a group of people who have been told they are crazy too many times to count. Why would anyone return to counter cultural teachings and strange rituals, if there was nothing else that compelled them or grabbed their imagination?
It's a slow response initially. But there are moving statements...
Child Of God #meaningfulchurchjargon
— Sarah Holz (@saritabonita89) February 1, 2014
Love your neighbor #meaningfulchurchjargon
— Tom Lutes (@lutes_thomasp) February 1, 2014
"We are all one body." #meaningfulchurchjargon
— Amanda Lutes (@amandamlutes) February 1, 2014
@lutes_thomasp take this bread
— Lisa Wiens Heinsohn (@Lisa_Wiens_H) February 1, 2014
@lutes_thomasp mystery. redemption. communion. for starters...
— Krista Tippett (@kristatippett) February 1, 2014
So. Let me ask you. What is your #meaningfulchurchjargon?
No comments:
Post a Comment